Middle Eastern Students Speak Out


I must have passed by the Islamic Cultural Center of Northern California in Oakland many times, but never noticed it. This center was the site for a Sanctuary Education conference held in Oakland on a Saturday in February.

Islamic Cultural Center Source Archnet
Islamic Cultural Center of Northern California. Source: Archnet

        The conference, for K-12 teachers, staff, and youth workers, was organized by a coalition of groups, including the Arab Resource & Organizing Center, Middle East Children’s Alliance (MECA), and the progressive educator magazine, Rethinking Schools. It was designed to address the needs of Arab and Muslim youth in these often-contentious times.

Flyer Sanctuary Educ Conf Source MECA

“Many teachers came to MECA. For five to six years, we got lots of invitations from schools to talk about refugees,” a MECA employee told me. He defined sanctuary education. “It’s when students and teachers can come to school and feel safe and, as a community, can protect each other. It’s the survival stage when there’s chaos. People need to come together. Students with themselves. Students and teachers. And students, teachers, and the community. To create a safe space.”

Approximately 200 people attended the conference.  They came from a wide array of ethnic backgrounds (e.g., Middle Eastern, Black, Latino, Asian, South Asian, and Caucasian). Participants work in many places, including East Oakland. According to organizers, hundreds more wanted to attend the conference, but there wasn’t space for them.

When participants arrived, conference security volunteers wearing pink armbands and members of the Muslim community greeted them at the entrance to the property. Inside, conference attendees picked up folders in a wood-paneled hallway that was carpeted with beautiful Iranian rugs. Books for children about Islam, Arabs, and the Middle East were for sale (e.g., Rukhsana Khan’s Muslim Child: A Collection of Short Stories and Poems). On the walls hung posters about the contributions of Muslims, such as Discover the Muslim Scientific Heritage in Our Markets, and addressed questions that are often asked of Muslims, such as How Does Islam Elevate the Status of Women and Is Islam Tolerant of Other Beliefs?

Poster Muslim Home Sanc Educ 2017.2.18The conference began with a general session held in a large, beautifully wood-paneled, white-domed room with seats down the middle and on three sides. Burgundy-colored drapes hung behind a slightly-raised dais, on which sat four students, members of a student panel.

Sitting Attendees Sanc educ 2017.2.18

Talking Attendees Sanc Educ 2017.2.18

Lara Kiswani (AROC) welcomed attendees and asked, “What does it mean to protect our students?” “It’s good we’re starting, but it’s just a beginning,” reminded Jody Sokolower of Rethinking Schools.

The students on the panel then shared their experiences. “I’ve always been a minority because I’ve never been in a school with a lot of Muslims or Arabs. I’ve felt discrimination, like when I’ve seen MUNI bus ads promoting anti-Palestinian feeling,” said 16 -year-old Rania, whose family is Palestinian.

Rania Sanc Educ 2017.2.18
Rania, student panelist. Photo by Katharine Davies Samway.

This feeling of being alone was shared by other panelists, who commented on the lack of attention paid to their Middle Eastern and Muslim cultures and religious backgrounds in school.

“Our culture is based on brotherhood and I didn’t have any of that because I was isolated,” said Abdul, who was the only Algerian at his high school. “It pushed me to learn English and learn about other cultures. I was surrounded by many Latinos and I shared some things with them. Soccer. The struggle.” He came to the U.S. about five years ago and is now attending San Francisco State University.

Nader came from Yemen about four years ago and he talked about how he was mistreated and questioned when he arrived in the U.S. “They asked me a lot of questions. About my videos. My camera. Why they do that for me? Because I’m Muslim? Because I’m Arab? Why they treat me like this?” Nader asked.

Protesters at SFO 2017.3.10 Source Getty AFP
Protesting the Muslim ban at SFO in March. Source: Getty AFP

“Did you see yourselves in textbooks?” asked the moderator of the student panel, Sharif Zakout, AROC’s Youth Program Coordinator.

“Yes and no,” Abdul said.  “There was nothing in the textbook about Algeria. The schools are losing out. It’s not until I took an ethnic studies class. It helped me see how it all relates. It helped me understand why I didn’t find anything about Algeria in the textbook.”

The other students agreed. “Palestine is never talked about and when it is, it’s about Israel,” said Rania, underscoring how a people and a history can be so easily misrepresented and ignored.

Map of ME countries of Ss
Countries of origin of student panelists

“No. Nobody knows about my country. Nobody knows about the war in Yemen,” Nader said. “There should be an Arabic class in high school.”

Nora shared an experience she had in high school when she was excited to learn that they would read a book whose protagonist was Middle Eastern. However, it turned out that the main character was a terrorist.

“I brought it up in front of the class and the teacher shut me down and said, ‘It’s just part of the plot.’” Nora also told the audience about times when she was humiliated for wearing hijab: “I’ve had teachers who were patronizing about wearing the scarf. ‘Are you sure you want to wear the scarf?’ they asked. ‘Yeah, I do,’ I’d say.”

Rania commented on the weaknesses of an educational system in which ethnic studies is often an elective and teachers are obliged to use adopted textbooks. “Ethnic studies is an elective (at her high school) and it doesn’t even count as History,” Rania said. ” Teachers are mandated to teach out of the book.”

When the moderator, Zakout, asked what would help and what teachers should do to make school a safe place, the students had lots of suggestions.

“Let organizations like AROC into the schools. Encourage critical thinking rather than shutting down students of color,” Nora said. “Be critical of on-campus law enforcement police officers. With the laws that are being passed, it’s going to be ICE that will be enforcing them. We need you teachers to speak actions versus words. We expect you teachers to put your bodies on the line.”

Rania & Nora Sanc Educ 2017.2.18
Nora, left, and Rania. Photo by Katharine Davies Samway.

The students were asked what their thoughts were about the new president. “No-one feels safe,”  Nader said. However, Rania pointed out that this attack on Middle Easterners, Muslims, and immigrants didn’t start with the new president. “There were more deportations under Obama and he bombed East Africa,” she reminded audience members.

At the end of the student panel, Nora commented on how anger can be transformed into something positive, and made a request of teachers: “You need to encourage anger, anger that is channeled into activism, that leads to positive change.” Rania appealed to the audience to look out for students like her: “You guys have our futures in your hands, so take care of it,” she said.

Author Profile

Katharine Davies Samway has lived in Oakland for over 35 years. She is a long-term educator — a teacher, a researcher, a teacher educator, a professor of education.

1 Comment

  1. One of the great joys of the classroom is learning about other cultures, and ways of life. Teachers should not be hampered by being forced to “teach to the text” when they have a wealth of diversity in the classroom itself. Allowing students to share their experiences of diversity is far more enriching than a textbook. Courage, teachers! Open your hearts and use your best judgement!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.